Wade & Butcher Boone fixed blade
Moderator: The Motley Crew
Forum rules
There are a few things you should know before posting in these forums. If you are a new user, please click here and read carefully. Thanks a lot!
There are a few things you should know before posting in these forums. If you are a new user, please click here and read carefully. Thanks a lot!
Wade & Butcher Boone fixed blade
My most recent find is this Wade & Butcher "Boone" carbon steel hunting knife.
It was discovered together with several other vintage hunting knives in an old leather hunting bag from the 1930's somewhere in Amsterdam.
The steel has gotten a dark grey patina from being stored inside the sheath for decennia.
On the blade the letters "ILLWELL" are very faintly visible, and through Google i found that originally it spelled "GILLWELL", which is the 144 acre sight North of London given to the Scouts in 1919 and now the worlds historical site for scouts.
It seems that the change from "GILLWELL" to "GILWELL" took place when Baden Powell was made the first Baron Baden-Powell of Gilwell in 1929.
So in 1919, when the first Wood Badge course was held, it was Gillwell Park.
If the info from Google is correct that would date my knife to have been manufactured between 1919 and 1929, although the sheath is probably not original to the knife but most likely from Scandinavian origin.
What do you guys think ?
It was discovered together with several other vintage hunting knives in an old leather hunting bag from the 1930's somewhere in Amsterdam.
The steel has gotten a dark grey patina from being stored inside the sheath for decennia.
On the blade the letters "ILLWELL" are very faintly visible, and through Google i found that originally it spelled "GILLWELL", which is the 144 acre sight North of London given to the Scouts in 1919 and now the worlds historical site for scouts.
It seems that the change from "GILLWELL" to "GILWELL" took place when Baden Powell was made the first Baron Baden-Powell of Gilwell in 1929.
So in 1919, when the first Wood Badge course was held, it was Gillwell Park.
If the info from Google is correct that would date my knife to have been manufactured between 1919 and 1929, although the sheath is probably not original to the knife but most likely from Scandinavian origin.
What do you guys think ?
Re: Wade & Butcher Boone fixed blade
Currently i'm doing a bit of online research on what kind of steel was used in these knives, and according to this old ad the Boone blades were made from (the famous) Wardlow steel.
Then i found these posts from 2017 on a forum:
Question: "What type of knife was used by Camillus in the early years, was it 1095 ?
I have a stockman made between 1920 and 1930, use it every day for carving, sharpest pocket knife I every had.
I am 64 years old this steel beats them all."
Answer: "Camillus forged their blades from Wardlow's best crucible steel from Sheffield England."
Reply: "All I know this blade steel is great, I carve 4 to 6 hours a day, sometime just strop and keep cutting.
My new pocket knives will not do this no matter the brand."
And from Bladeforums: "The S. & C. Wardlow steel that Camillus imported from Sheffield, England, was derived from about 8o percent pure Swedish iron ore; wide variation in heating did not injure it."
Then i found these posts from 2017 on a forum:
Question: "What type of knife was used by Camillus in the early years, was it 1095 ?
I have a stockman made between 1920 and 1930, use it every day for carving, sharpest pocket knife I every had.
I am 64 years old this steel beats them all."
Answer: "Camillus forged their blades from Wardlow's best crucible steel from Sheffield England."
Reply: "All I know this blade steel is great, I carve 4 to 6 hours a day, sometime just strop and keep cutting.
My new pocket knives will not do this no matter the brand."
And from Bladeforums: "The S. & C. Wardlow steel that Camillus imported from Sheffield, England, was derived from about 8o percent pure Swedish iron ore; wide variation in heating did not injure it."
Re: Wade & Butcher Boone fixed blade
This Pathe footage from 1949 shows the actual making of the crucibles and how they were used to produce cast steel:
https://www.britishpathe.com/video/hand ... /foundries
The first reaction below almost the footage on YouTube (but without sound) reads this:
"George Goodwin, puddling clay for the making of pots for melting crucible steel, looks like the old Benjamin Huntsman works on Coleridge Rd.
I started work there in 1968 as a lad in the forge, George by then was much older and working in the warehouse, he told us lads of these days making pots, and was still a very fit and muscular guy, bulging biceps for a pensioner a fantastic bloke.
A piece of Sheffield history here..... Bob."
https://www.britishpathe.com/video/hand ... /foundries
The first reaction below almost the footage on YouTube (but without sound) reads this:
"George Goodwin, puddling clay for the making of pots for melting crucible steel, looks like the old Benjamin Huntsman works on Coleridge Rd.
I started work there in 1968 as a lad in the forge, George by then was much older and working in the warehouse, he told us lads of these days making pots, and was still a very fit and muscular guy, bulging biceps for a pensioner a fantastic bloke.
A piece of Sheffield history here..... Bob."
Re: Wade & Butcher Boone fixed blade
The owner of this Wade & Butcher Boone knife also seems quite happy with the edge holding of his knife:
https://www.thehuntinglife.com/forums/t ... -fanatics/
https://www.thehuntinglife.com/forums/t ... -fanatics/
Re: Wade & Butcher Boone fixed blade
Originally the blade used to be full convex ground, but sometime during it's existence a previous owner had sharpened a bit of a rough secundairy bevel into it.
So i reground the blade by hand to full convex again on 400 grit wet & dry using WD40 oil as a lubricant on a medium hard rubber backing (old piece of fiber reinforced conveyor belt)
The old blunt "edge" measured between 35 and 40 degrees inclusive, while the new edge apex fits almost exactly in the (specifically aimed for) 30 degrees inclusive slot of my Tormek WM200 Angle Master.
I do consider this a bit on the conservative side, as i think the steel can most likely handle a thinner edge geometry just fine, but for now i want to play it safe with this rare & valuable knife (to me anyway)
If need be further thinning can always be done later.
There is still a tiny burr on the apex, next step will be to refine the scratch pattern with probably 800 grit wet & dry.
After that the plan is to recut the swedge with a small diamond file followed by wet & dry paper & some WD40.
The handle has already been smooth sanded with 400 grit wet & dry and treated with several coats of warm Granger's wax.
So i reground the blade by hand to full convex again on 400 grit wet & dry using WD40 oil as a lubricant on a medium hard rubber backing (old piece of fiber reinforced conveyor belt)
The old blunt "edge" measured between 35 and 40 degrees inclusive, while the new edge apex fits almost exactly in the (specifically aimed for) 30 degrees inclusive slot of my Tormek WM200 Angle Master.
I do consider this a bit on the conservative side, as i think the steel can most likely handle a thinner edge geometry just fine, but for now i want to play it safe with this rare & valuable knife (to me anyway)
If need be further thinning can always be done later.
There is still a tiny burr on the apex, next step will be to refine the scratch pattern with probably 800 grit wet & dry.
After that the plan is to recut the swedge with a small diamond file followed by wet & dry paper & some WD40.
The handle has already been smooth sanded with 400 grit wet & dry and treated with several coats of warm Granger's wax.
Re: Wade & Butcher Boone fixed blade
Some more vintage footage about old school knife making in Sheffield:
Bridlington, October 1978
After 72 years as a blade forger in Sheffield, Albert Craven has finally decided to retire.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zpeyhC-UIFg
Two knife grinders at work:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qfXYBheE_Fs
A website dedicated to various things Sheffield, among which several clips related to knife making:
Little Mesters – Alex Glen Wilson
Footage from the 1960's where the same George Goodwin (now 77 years old) shows how he makes the crucibles:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tOS05k1C7zM
Also this fascinating color documentary made in 1945 about large scale steel manufacture in Sheffield.
In the beginning there is even some footage of crucible steel manufacture.
British Council Film: Steel
Bridlington, October 1978
After 72 years as a blade forger in Sheffield, Albert Craven has finally decided to retire.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zpeyhC-UIFg
Two knife grinders at work:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qfXYBheE_Fs
A website dedicated to various things Sheffield, among which several clips related to knife making:
Little Mesters – Alex Glen Wilson
Footage from the 1960's where the same George Goodwin (now 77 years old) shows how he makes the crucibles:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tOS05k1C7zM
Also this fascinating color documentary made in 1945 about large scale steel manufacture in Sheffield.
In the beginning there is even some footage of crucible steel manufacture.
British Council Film: Steel
Re: Wade & Butcher Boone fixed blade
The blade has been refined through grit 800 and 1000 wet & dry (again using WD40 on the piece of conveyor belt), removed the very fine burr on the Tormek leather wheel, and the apex can now whittle one of my chest hairs from root-to-tip at about 3.0 centimeters from the point of holding.
Also polished the aluminium pommel a bit on a felt wheel, recut the swedge & jimping with a few small diamond files, and next step is to refine the swedge surfaces a bit more.
This is how the knife currently looks:
Also polished the aluminium pommel a bit on a felt wheel, recut the swedge & jimping with a few small diamond files, and next step is to refine the swedge surfaces a bit more.
This is how the knife currently looks:
Re: Wade & Butcher Boone fixed blade
Kwackster
I really love that knife.
I knew Wade and Butcher made some magnificent straight razors and bowie knives/dirks etc plus some army jackknives in ww1 and ww2 but thanks for the info on the Sheffield steel /Wardlows and its composition using swedish steel.
I live about 45 miles from Sheffield and ashamedly havn't visited the museums or the little meisters there due to lack of time at the moment .
The knife you have ,as well as the scouts connection, is a style sometimes attributed to soldiers /pilots private purchases in ww2 and I love the blade shape and the leather handle .
You have made a great job of restoring it as usual and have found yet another knife I would love to own.
Hope your well and thanks for the interesting information and how you restore these knives.
Ian
I really love that knife.
I knew Wade and Butcher made some magnificent straight razors and bowie knives/dirks etc plus some army jackknives in ww1 and ww2 but thanks for the info on the Sheffield steel /Wardlows and its composition using swedish steel.
I live about 45 miles from Sheffield and ashamedly havn't visited the museums or the little meisters there due to lack of time at the moment .
The knife you have ,as well as the scouts connection, is a style sometimes attributed to soldiers /pilots private purchases in ww2 and I love the blade shape and the leather handle .
You have made a great job of restoring it as usual and have found yet another knife I would love to own.
Hope your well and thanks for the interesting information and how you restore these knives.
Ian
-
- Posts: 4045
- Joined: Sat Mar 26, 2016 7:18 pm
- Location: Indiana
Re: Wade & Butcher Boone fixed blade
What Sammy said!
Polish a knife, cook a pig, drink several beers
Re: Wade & Butcher Boone fixed blade
Hello, I have the Boone version of this knife in pretty good condition without a sheath. One the blade is etched Boone and on the blade the name of the company and Sheffield england. On all the pictures that I’ve see of similar knives there is also a logo etched on the opposite side of the knive from where the company name is. Could it me a mistake that there was no logo? On knives where the logo was worn away by time usually can see something. I’m wondering if this could have been made without the logo. Thank you for any help.
https://flic.kr/p/2mdWjEi
https://flic.kr/p/2me4PuR
https://flic.kr/p/2mdWjEi
https://flic.kr/p/2me4PuR